The Citadel

The Military College of South Carolina

ocl6.jpg

Judging Criteria

Guide for Judges

Judges will use criteria similar to that used by Toastmasters, International when that organization conducts its international speech contest. Below is a breakdown of the criteria: 

Content:
Speech Development (structure, organization, support material).
 
A good speech will be
  • Easy to understand
  • Focused (has a purpose)
  • Structured (clear beginning, middle, and end)
  • Engaging (gets audience attention and drives them to a purpose)
  • Supported with relevant examples, facts, etc.
Topic (achieves purpose, holds interest)
  • Was the speech subject appropriate for this particular audience?
 
Delivery:
Stage presence
  • Professional appearance
  • Body language should support speech through gestures, expressions, posture.
  • Speaker moves appropriately
  • Speaker exhibits enthusiasm and confidence
Voice
  • Different pitches, rate, and volume add to richness of speech.
  • Words heard and clearly understood.
 
Language:
  • Word choices appropriate for audience.
  • Language is precise and promotes clear understanding of thoughts
  • Use of words is correct in terms of grammar and pronunciation.
  • Speaker uses few or no filler words.
Back to Top